"You got me.". And he offered a matter-of-fact reply when asked how he came to sell a fraudulent item. LLCs are a simple and inexpensive way to protect your personal assets and save money on taxes. 1992 Classic #BC22 Derek Jeter ROOKIE Card New York Yankees Future Hall of Famer! The Sullivans didn't know what to do. The item arrived on Friday. But the barrier for entry was low, Fitzsimmons said, and some authenticators were later ostracized for making dubious determinations. "It's not even signed with an implement that was used at the time.". Ingber also denied knowingly selling pieces of sports memorabilia that weren't genuine. Liberty Head (21) Indian Head (16) Saint-Gaudens (14) Modern (15) Silver. View cart for details. In one of the messages, Sullivan said the family was going to consider "getting the proper authorities involved in investigating such fraud unless we can come to a reasonable accommodation.". 3701 Sirius Avenue, Las Vegas, NV 89102 Map. Please add me to your list of favorite sellers. i'm trying to get an authentic birthday present and i'm not sure who i can trust. Perullo showed up to the interview in a long-sleeve purple shirt and khaki pants, holding a medium-sized cup of coffee filled to the top. Joe DiMaggio and Mickey Mantle of the New York Yankees pose with Ted Williams of the Boston Red Sox before Opening Day in 1951 at Yankee Stadium in New York. Unauthenticated, sold as is. Ceramics Hand Made Man On Bench With Dog Figurine, T.P. Tip for consumers:Scam, reverse image search the product before you buy it! When she was in eighth grade, it was Kerr who bought her a graduation dress. Classic Sportsman Sporting Goods Website 13 YEARS IN BUSINESS (973) 291-8911 9 Moonshadow Ct Kinnelon, NJ 07405 7. They simply list items from other sites at inflated prices. It was a small business if it even was one at all. Backed by the National Science Foundation, Trying to Sell HIGH-END Memorabilia without the Owner's Permission, Definitely the place to look for niche sports collectibles, Reseller of active ebay items that are not theirs. Ripoff Report | Complaints Reviews Scams Lawsuits Frauds Reported. Classic Cars, Sports or Celebrity memorabilia, Antiques, Music equipment, coins and currency, collectible toys, comic books, stamps, jewelry and more! That's great, Cory. Kerr, who spent 28 years with the Kearny Fire Department, had a long relationship with Sullivan's mother. Watch Live TV. Menu . ADDITIONAL LINKS Post Question For This Company Contact Us Regarding Your Company Profile Display cases add value to your collectible and protect it for years to come. Corporate Advocacy Program - Verified Status, How To Get Your Report Featured On All Report Pages. Our auction lots will showcase our diverse and exceptional collection of NCAA, NFL, MLB and NBA authentic autographed memorabilia. Bad company? My Cart. Sports memorabilia tied to modern players is far more likely to be legitimate, experts say, because a plethora of companies now perform witnessed signings and uniquely identify the items with holograms to deter fraud. Schoenack worked for the now-defunct company, Collectors Source, from 1997 to 2009. The family reached out to NBC News through a relative who works for the company. Please ask specific questions on details, condition, and shipping prior to bidding, ALL ITEMS ARE SOLD AS IS, and the bidder will be responsible for payment. Toll Free (888)-228-7320. Ingber insisted that he had an "excellent relationship with 99 percent" of his customers. We value your privacy! Gave me an expample of one his "long term clients" that bought a stamp for $750 then sold it 3 years later for $6,000. Ralph Perullo assesses signatures on two baseballs. Our growing brand is recognizable in the sports memorabilia industry and is synonymous with excellence, authenticity and great value. Set up Accounting for your Sport Memorabilia Business. Sports Collectibles also offers a 100% Money Back Guarantee on all of our items. 0 Likes, by Greg Jeranek Their A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau makes us confident in recommending them as a high-rated retailer for sports memorabilia. Had to contact eBay seller and wasted 2 hours of my time having to research on the shadiness of this company so that I could be reassured about my legitimate eBay purchase. . All of our items come with a Certificate of Authenticity and are 100% authentic. Privacy Policy | I noticed shortly after, that their site had a photo of the exact, psa/dna serial numbered item on their site! They are liars and cheats. Terms of Service. Chipper Jones 1990 Classic Draft Picks Autographed Card #1 - PSA/DNA, 1996 Classic Kyle Wachholtz Autographed Football Card #NNO, 1992 Classic #85 Greg Dennis NBA Basketball Trading Card, Chipper Jones Rookie Card 1990 Classic Yellow #T92 BGS 9.5, Bo Jackson Rookie Card 1987 Classic Update Yellow #109 PSA 7, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Draft Picks Bonus Foil #BC6 AGS 8 NM/MT, 1995 Classic NFL Rookies #2 Tony Boselli NFL Football Trading Card, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1993 Classic Best Gold #115 PSA 9, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Four Sport #231 BGS 9 (9.5 9 9 8.5), 1988 Classic Blue #MMDM Mark McGwire w/Don Mattingly Rookie Card - Mint Condition Ships in New Holder, 1994 Classic #47 Larry Allen NFL Football Trading Card, Shaquille O'Neal 1992-93 Classic Four Sport Autograph Rookie Card #318 PSA/DNA 10, Joe Montana 1993 Classic Pro Line Live Autograph Card #124 PSA/DNA 10, Ken Griffey Jr 1989 Classic Travel Autograph Rookie Card #193 PSA/DNA, Pedro Martinez 1991 Classic Best Autograph Rookie Card #355 PSA/DNA 10, Ken Griffey Jr 1989 Classic Travel Autograph Rookie Card #193 PSA/DNA 10, Ken Griffey Jr 1989 Classic Travel Autograph Rookie Card #131 PSA/DNA 10, Nolan Ryan Card 1990 Classic Blue #1 BGS BCCG 8, Cal Ripken Jr Card 1991 Classic II #T3 BGS BCCG 10, Shaquille O'Neal 1992-93 Classic Autograph Rookie Card #1 PSA/DNA, Chipper Jones Rookie Card 1992 Classic Best #1 AGS 8 NM/MT, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1993 Classic Sudden Impact #SI3 AGS 8 NM/MT, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Draft Picks Four Sport #231 AGS 9 MINT, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Best #402 AGS 8 NM/MT, Chipper Jones Rookie Card 1992 Classic Best #1 AGS 9 MINT, B.Zito w/Clemens-Halladay 2004 Classic Clippings All-Star Lineup Swatch #BZ, D.Willis w/Castillo-Lowell 2004 Classic Clippings All-Star Lineup Swatch #DW, Bret Boone Card 2005 Classic Clippings MLB Game Worn Jersey Collection #29, Michael Young Card 2005 Classic Clippings MLB Game Worn Jersey Collection #23, A.Jones w/Sheffield-Javy Card 2004 Classic Clippings All-Star Lineup Swatch #AJ, Jason Kendall Card 2005 Classic Clippings MLB Game Worn Jersey Collection #36, Omar Vizquel Card 2005 Classic Clippings MLB Game Worn Jersey Collection #31, Frank Thomas Rookie Card 1990 Classic Yellow #T93 PSA 9, Chipper Jones Rookie Card 1992 Classic Best Red Bonus #BC7 PSA 9, 1996 Classic Eddie George Oilers Rookie Football Card #13, 1994-95 Classic #70 HAKEEM OLAJUWON Basketball, Albert Pujols Card 2004 Classic Clippings Jersey Rack Autographs Bronze BGS 8, Nomar Garciaparra Rookie Card 1994 Classic 4 Sport #173 PSA 9, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Draft Picks #6 PSA 8, Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Draft Picks Foil Bonus #BC6 PSA 8, 1995 Classic Tony McGee Bengals 240/1385 Autographed Football Card #PLC-TM. Perullo immediately put the items on the market in that summer of 1999. My dad is a huge sports fan and they pulled through for me every time. Auctioneer Information West Coast Auction Co. (941) 468-7815 View Full Catalog Details Bid History Auction Info Terms Item Location Auction Contacts Pick Up Times MUHAMMAD ALI AUTOGRAPHED 8 X 10 PHOTO COMES FRAMED WITH COA ISSUED BY CLASSIC SPORTS COLLECTIBLES, LLC. A Derek Jeter-signed bat back on sale at a price of $695. "Unfortunately, it's too easy a crime to commit," Tim Fitzsimmons, a retired FBI agent, said. The seller on Ebay said he was aware of his prints being sold on this website, except he can't do anything about them. Consumers educating consumers., Complaints Reviews Scams Lawsuits Frauds Reported.. We are the nation's top buyer of vintage sports cards and memorabilia. "His m.o. Buy a EZ PAY for this firearm is 18 payments of $60.00 <br ><br > This is the total amount you will pay for sale by OutDoor Sports LLC on GunsAmerica.com the best online marketplace for buying and selling semi auto pistols, firearms, accessories, and collectibles : 965227994 '", She said customers often called to complained about the items they had purchased. All rights reserved. Then, if you are dumb enough to purchase it from them, they buy it from the unsuspecting seller on ebay (often after making a low ball offer to the seller), then the give the ebay seller their customers address making the ebay seller an unsuspecting drop shipper. By getting in on the ground level, some good luck and good guidance, RMM (or anyone else) could also see those types of returns. According to the customer service ticket on their website, Derek closed by inquiry with the status of "resolved", even though i was not contacted and no information was provided to me. But after he was presented with the email itself, Perullo suggested that someone else must have written it. Bogus Celebrity Advertisements FACE & Skin CREAM Ripoff! "Willie wouldn't sign that ball," Perullo said. A second authenticator, PSA, also determined that they were inauthentic. "It's been a nightmare," she told NBC News. Yet, despite its notoriety, many don't know that an Austin Healey model set several land speed records in 1953 at the Bonneville Salt Flats in Utah, in the United States. I would make a recommendation to any former player or any family that has lost their loved one, that they get in touch with Classic Auctions and have them catalogue the memorabilia and they'll be very happy with the results." Silver Plated Repose Flask Berry Silver Co. International Sterling Silver Half Pint Flask #855, Meriden B Company Silver Plate Flask with Hunt Scene Motif, James Dixson & Sons Sheffield Large Two Spout Flask L1985, Art Deco Sterling Silver One Pint Flask Circa 1902, Wahl Eversharp Gold Seal Manifold Fountain Pen Marbleized Green, Emerald and Diamond Bracelet Mounted in 14K Gold, Israeli Electroform Decorative Flowers Bouquets, Rickshaw Cart Sterling Men's Tie Bar and Cufflink Set, A momento of the 1987 Maiden Voyage of the "New Queen Elizabeth" 2, Hires Ginger Champanale Glasses Lot Of Three, Praktica BMS 35mm SLR Camera with Original Flash and Case. I added images with an example of an item they are selling that is currently for sale on eBay by another seller. They can't prove anything.'". Tip for consumers:just to stay away and buy the items directly from the actual sellers on ebay. Although the two never married, he treated Sullivan as his daughter. Autograph Live: How to use our Musician-Direct Autograph Sales Forum. "There's no shot of that particular autograph being valid," Spence said. She contributes to "Nightly News with Lester Holt," "TODAY" and MSNBC. For a closer look at the signature please refer to the images provided. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. Yamaha XT 600 was suitable for both on-road and off-road driving. Copyright 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Customer Service Rep Ryan M took my order and made sure he packed the item up and drove it to FedEx after hours. Bought an autographed picture and waited a few weeks without hearing anything. Pricing was fair and shipment was received in reasonable time. Bought a jersey and then cancelled my order took my money and gave me a receipt. Really happy with the quality and delivery of my collectibles. PLEASE MAKE IT POINT TO STOP IN OR SEND A FRIEND TO PICK UP FOR YOU! The email said Perullo's "attorney in New Jersey" advised him to file a lien against Kerr's estate and file a credit report against her name. Would absolutely recommend buying from these guys, prices are very competitive! For a closer look at the photograph please refer to the images provi 20. As far as customer service Well, I couldn't tell you a thing about them-But, see, that's really a good thing, because it means I had zero issues with my transaction. Classic & Collectible Cars - Serving Las Vegas, NV. The mother of two from Nutley, New Jersey, was at her office in early October 2018 when she heard a phone ringing in her purse. Submit your email to receive the latest stories and expert advice They said they wanted to speak out to warn others of the pitfalls in buying sports memorabilia. Potential buyers are urged Local business Classic Materials Sports & Collectibles | San Francisco CA A baseball said to be signed by the 1932 World Series Champion New York Yankees? Buyer's Premium. All rights reserved. Ingber went further, calling Sullivan's place of work, a hedge fund in New York City. Friendly and reliable. Some guy Randy called me today saying we had talked 4 months ago and he had sent me some information..none of which I remembered. I will continue to shop here in the future. New Jersey (US) of a company he or she never even did business with. Sullivan had no way of knowing at the outset, but Kerr had been drawn into the web of a dealer who was at one time a well-known player in the industry. 0 Likes, by Greg Jeranek Donate Aircraft; Open a Business Bank Account & Credit Card. Verify your business to immediately update business information, track page views, and more! The best way to protect your new piece of sports memorabilia is to add a display case. They sent me an email with a usps link for my order and the link was blank. They knew little about him other than that he was based outside Minneapolis and seemed to be in business with a Ralph Perullo from North Carolina. Charles Kerr jumped at any chance to buy a special piece of sports memorabilia. The retired firefighter from New Jersey was so proud of his collection and so confident of its value that he would tell his longtime partner's daughter, Jennifer Sullivan, she didn't have to worry about coming up with the money to pay for her two young children's college education. Although the information published herein is from sources deemed Rare Collectibles TV. on orders $199+ Dave & Adam's Premier Rewards Program Level Up and Unlock automatic rewards with every dollar you spend Learn More New Releases 2022 Panini Mosaic Baseball Hobby Box $129.95 $94.95 Add to Cart 2021/22 Panini Mosaic Basketball Hobby Box $429.95 $379.95 Add to Cart 2022 Panini Donruss Football Hobby Box $274.95 Add to Cart He said he couldn't believe his eyes at first. But it's not just former customers who cast Perullo's business practices in a poor light. Thank you guys for being awesome! Affiliated Auctions & Realty (5982) (850) 656-5486 Catalog Terms of sale Search Catalog : Search Sort By : Go to Lot : Go Go to Page : Go Per Page : Pg : 9 of 24 All > Autographed items: Return To Catalog. Perullo was brought on to help run the business around 2007. . He claimed to her boss that she had used her work email to threaten him, Sullivan said. I am so happy I did! We box and ship what we can to keep costs low, and use USPS and UPS. I reverse searched the image and found the same exact photo being sold on ebay for $250! It took Perullo less than five seconds to declare that the Willie Mays signature was fake. It seems RMM has plenty of extra time to spend fully digesting an entire phone presentation and then writing it all down in the form of a scathing review . connected to the hottest items and auction trends. "That's a good question," he said. He brought four autographed baseballs including one signed by Joe DiMaggio and another signed by Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb to a sports show in upstate New York where a leading authentication company, JSA, was reviewing merchandise. reliable, AuctionZip.com expressly disclaims any liability for errors, omissions or Rolled condition with some minor edge tears. Classic Sports Inc Collectibles 99.6% Positive feedback 10K Items sold 159 Followers Share Save Seller Shop Shop About About Feedback Feedback All items Sort: San Francisco 49ers 5-Time Super Bowl Champions Pin - Limited 1,000 $9.95 FIFA 2022 World Cup Qatar Two-Tone Gold 3-D Logo Pin - 1.25"$7.95 they cannot deliver what they say an insane amount of money Pittsburgh Pennsylvania, Attorney Sharon K. Campbell COLLUDES with Wells Fargo Dallas Texas, BlackSwanCapital.co Black Swan Enterprises Peter Tumbas Black Swan Capital The offered guaranteed low-cost financing if I first stepped in high-cost short term financing New York New York, Geeks Ondemand LLC, Lizeth Lagomarcino Papaleo Geeks Ondemand LLC, The Geeks Mob SCAM! For a closer look at the signature please refer to the images provided. Our records show it was established in 1959 an, I have been going to Targeteers for over 10 years. A total of 18 items had now been tested, and Perullo was batting zero for 18. Additional Details. Perullo also stayed composed when told that all 11 of the items tested from Kerr's collection were determined to be inauthentic. The value of the items skyrocketed, and fraudsters pounced. They helped me find the prized football helmet I had been scouring for on eBay for months! In 2000, Fitzsimmons helped take down a nationwide counterfeiting ring that made millions largely off the pen of a master forger who needed only blank balls, bats and aged pieces of paper. Is sportscollectibles a scam or a legit company? Jurisdiction. After working with him for two years, Schoenack came to believe that Perullo was "just plain crooked all the way around. Company Number. On December 16th I contacted customer service for a status of the order because I needed to know when it would be shipping. Our companies original nam, Located just minutes from the New Jersey/New York State border, Ramapo Saddlery has been serving the needs of our local equestrian community for over 30 years. Today, the retired FBI agent estimates that roughly 50 percent of vintage sports memorabilia on the market is fraudulent. The rarest of pieces sell for jaw-dropping prices. 3 Comments "I am really scared of these people," said one of the men. James Spence's company specializes in autograph authentication. "That these items were going to take care of us in the long run. This is actually illegal. We buy collections of all types every day! IN 3 WEEKS THEY SENT 3 OF MY RECIPIENTS DEAD FROZEN TINY BOUQUETS calgary, Ponce motors Deceptive car sales Austin Texas, Nextiva efax overcharged me for an entire year even before the monthly trial expired able to use the service at all. I love dealing with sports collectibles. I do not think it is in operation anymore and could find no info about who owned it, or discussions on this site. We have a 100% money back policy on autographs up to 6 months from day of purchase. Say we owe over $22,000.00 for the rest of their so called contract !!!!!!